Friday, December 12, 2014
Final Paper Fall Semester
Running head: CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 1
Macro Group Assignment
Contextualizing the Problem
Child Sexual Abuse Awareness and Prevention
Katie Bingham
Laurel Mallonee
Cameron Cox
Diana Ballard
Ian Hancock
Social Justice, Human Rights and Macro Social Work Practice
December 12, 2014
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 2
Issue/Problem
Child sexual abuse is a nation-wide problem. It is insidious because close to eighty-nine
percent of the abuse that takes place is from a known perpetrator. The State of Utah, in the 2014
Legislative session passed House Bill 286 with new legislation mandating that the education
system provide Child Sex Abuse Prevention Programs in the schools
(H.B. 286 Child Sex Abuse Prevention, 2014 General Session). This was a huge victory for
advocates of Child Abuse Prevention. However, the community still lacks education and
awareness connecting the prevention piece to the home environment. According to Prevent Child
Abuse Utah, 4 out of 5 girls and 4 out of 6 boys are abused by the time that they turn 18. Almost
90% of the perpetrators are someone that the child knows.
Although having educational programs in the schools is an incredible step, it is not
enough. According to the CDC, it is important for parents to play an active role in the prevention
of child sex abuse. ” You may feel uncomfortable discussing sexuality with your kids, but it's
important… Find out what your school teaches. (CDC, 2007).
Child sexual abuse awareness and prevention is a widespread issue that affects society as
a whole, across all cultures and generations. The purpose of our group is to focus on child sexual
abuse education for the parents of children ages 0-17. The education of parents regarding child
sexual abuse awareness and prevention will empower parents and children, while focusing on the
open communication, trust, and respect needed to accomplish the goal of safe, happy, and
emotionally balanced children. Parents are very affected by the issue of child sexual abuse
awareness and prevention, because they are generally the closest, most trusted, and most
accessible source of information for their children. An educational training for parents would be
applicable, because it was found that parents’ knowledge of sexual abuse symptoms is limited. It
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 3
is advantageous for parents to be aware that warnings signs of child sexual abuse include
medical symptoms, unusual sexual behavior, and unusual sexual knowledge (Babatsikos, 2010,
p. 118). Parents were reluctant to discuss child sexual abuse with their children because many
were concerned about scaring them (Walsh & Brandon, 2012, p. 739). Parents also felt that they
lacked adequate awareness, knowledge, vocabulary, and material to confidently and effectively
talk to their children about this sensitive issue. Beginning the discussion early is beneficial
because it builds confidence and an open and trusting dialogue between parents and children
regarding sexual abuse and personal safety.
Causes of the Issue
Prevent Child Abuse Utah has found that parents are resistant to receiving information or
education around child sexual abuse in the venues they have tried. At this point, we are unsure
about the particular reasons that parents have this resistant attitude or what venues are successful.
While there is currently a fair amount of research on the benefits of parental involvement in a
child’s education of sexual abuse, there is very little on what strategies will engage parents or
why they are resistant (Wurtele 2009). Often schools or community agencies will offer
workshops, information booths, etc. to educate parents about child abuse, similar to the
experience of Prevent Child Abuse Utah, but parents do not seem to have a desire to approach
this topic or get the information that is available. As a group we have created a survey with
Prevent Child Abuse Utah that assesses parents’ existing knowledge and attitudes about child
sexual abuse education. There is not much in the literature regarding the topic, but a few smaller
studies have been done that may help us understand why some parents have this attitude.
Several studies have consistently shown that the majority of parents are willing to talk
about sexual abuse with their children, but they think they have correct and adequate information
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 4
to protect the child when they do not. For instance, some parents will talk about “stranger
danger”, and emphasize the idea that it is almost always strangers to watch out for. Few talk
about or are aware of the fact that most perpetrators of sexual abuse are by familiar figures in the
childrens’ lives. Parents may also tell the children that they only need to tell one person about
the abuse, when often the first person they tell does not believe them (Wurtele 2010).
Other possible reasons include “children perceived to be too young to understand
(certainly fathers felt this way), not wanting to frighten their children, and a lack of knowledge,
vocabulary and materials” (Walsh 2012). Some parents have reported that they simply don’t
have the resources to talk about sexual abuse with their children. Often, parents are getting their
information from the media which tends to display the more dramatic cases of abuse and gives
inaccurate information. Many parents have said in studies that they don’t believe their children
are at a very high risk for experiencing child abuse, so they do not feel that discussion of the
topic is necessary. Other parents have expressed concern that any discussion of sexual abuse
will lead to their children having “too much knowledge” about sex. (Wurtele 2010).
In a small study done in Australia, researchers conducted focus groups of parents, most
often mothers, of small children regarding their attitudes toward education in the schools. Many
of the parents related how their personal education of child abuse growing up was lacking, and
would like more for their children. The biggest stipulation was that parents wanted to have prior
knowledge of what was in the curriculum, and have the opportunity to be deeply involved in
what was being taught. Opinions differed, some saying parents should have some control over
what was being taught, and others disagreed, saying there are things parents don't know about
child abuse that the children should be taught (Walsh 2012). One conclusion drawn from this
study was that parents are willing to have education for their children from an outside source, but
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 5
do not necessarily know how to get involved. There are also widely differing opinions about the
age that this information should be taught, as well as the amount or content of the information.
These possibilities, while likely, are not backed by much research. Future studies are
required to get to the root of this particular problem. "Unfortunately, there are very few
rigorously evaluated programs, materials, or Web sites developed for parents. Although it is
feasible to recommend content for parent focused materials, the bigger challenge is how to
deliver such information. Typically, parent-focused workshops, often sponsored by schools, are
poorly attended. More research is needed to identify predisposing factors for parents
participation in CSA [Child Sexual Abuse] prevention programs. Research is also needed to
determine effective ways of recruiting parents. Clearly, parents will need to be reached in
innovative ways" (Wurtele 2009).
Effects and Consequences of the Issue
The primary consequence of this problem is that sexual abuse is occurring frequently in
Utah and all over the United States. It is estimated that thousands of children have been abused
and have not received help due to family secrecy and/or the child’s fear of standing up for
themselves. When speaking to a caseworker from Division of Child and Family Services, he
stated that many children continue to live in these situations because caregivers often do not
know who to report to or do not realize that they are not held liable when they report and that
their report will be kept confidential unless they request otherwise (B. Rachal, personal
communication, November 25, 2014). Often times, families state that they would rather keep the
family together and leaving the issue unaddressed rather than making a report, which can often
enable the perpetrator to continue offending. With all these factors considered, there may
considerably more children in Utah than we are aware of who are currently experiencing sexual
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 6
abuse and will not likely receive help until the trauma has already devastated their lives for
years.
When left unreported, the effects of sexual abuse are catastrophic. There are a wide
variety of likely consequences upon a child’s social, psychological, and emotional functioning
that usually affect a child for the rest of their life. According to Allen-Meares and Fraser, some
psychological symptoms include developing disorders such as Posttraumatic Stress Disorder,
Depression and Suicidal Ideation, and in severe cases even Dissociative Identity Disorder (2004).
In my experience as a mental health worker over the years, I have seen a substantial number of
clients in inpatient settings who had severe mental illness that were coinciding with histories of
sexual abuse. The past trauma can continue to be just as disabling to a person because they were
never given the opportunity to heal and grow. Since sexual abuse is often left unreported or is not
noticed for many years, it compounds the risk of developing such illness.
There are other cognitive and social effects of sexual abuse which include a higher risk of
sexually acting out upon others, hostile behavior towards others, and unsafe risk taking due to
trouble in moderating levels of arousal. Also, there tends to be decrease in school functioning,
especially in areas such as academic achievement, absences, and progress in verbal
communication (Allen-Meares & Fraser, 2004). Unfortunately, this can ultimately lead to a
generational cycle of abusive behavior if not addressed early on in a child’s life. There are
multiple cases of formerly abused parents committing abusive acts upon their children.
Also of deep concern is the growing trend of human sex trafficking and pornographic
exploitation within the United States and around the world. This can easily occur when overall
awareness of sexual abuse and exploitation is lacking in the community. When the signs of these
forms of maltreatment are unknown, predators are easily able to coerce children into such
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 7
servitude and the opportunity for preventative measures is lost. Unless it becomes socially
acceptable to discuss such issues in everyday conversation, this issue is likely to persist and
progress forward, as it already has.
Population most affected by the issue
Parents and children are the population most affected by the issue of child sexual abuse
awareness and prevention. Children 0-5 years old are a critical group to educate regarding
reporting and prevention strategies. They are especially vulnerable because of their young age,
and lack of awareness regarding appropriate touching and sexual issues. Fathers are another
group that would benefit from more information, education, and exposure regarding this topic,
because the majority of participants in studies about child sexual abuse and prevention education
are women (Babatsikos, 2010, p. 109). Mothers are already more involved, and having fathers
participate more in the sexual abuse education of their children would be beneficial. Girls are at
greater risk for child sexual abuse than boys. 10-20% of girls are known to be victims of child
abuse, and less than 10% of boys are found to be affected (Walsh and Brandon, 2012, p. 734).
Boys are also at risk and need to be taught awareness and prevention methods, but girls are more
affected than boys. Overall numbers are likely greater than these figures, this information is
based on reported cases. Families with a lower socioeconomic status and lower levels of
education are more affected by sexual abuse (Babatsikos, 2010, p. 118, 122). Step families or
blended families have a higher risk of child sexual abuse. Families where the mother has a
history of sexual abuse are also at a higher risk of a sexual abuse issues. When substance use or
alcohol use is involved, the risk of child sexual abuse increases. In families where other types of
abuse including physical abuse, verbal abuse, emotional abuse, or any type of neglect are
present, the probability of sexual abuse is also increased (Babatsikos, 2010, p. 125). Parents who
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 8
are uncomfortable discussing sexuality issues in general are less likely to have open dialogues
with their children about child sexual abuse and prevention. Increasing parents’ knowledge and
confidence in this area is an important goal.
When educating parents regarding child sexual abuse and awareness, it is important to
take into account that cultural norms may vary. Some cultures see child sexual abuse as
shameful, and parents may believe that children should not tell anyone about sexual abuse
(Babatsikos, 2010, p. 122). This is a population that may require knowledge and development of
different child sexual abuse awareness and prevention strategies. It is important to understand
and teach child sexual abuse issues in a culturally sensitive way. Research has found that factors
affecting parents’ attendance of sexual abuse awareness and prevention educational trainings
were affected by interest in the topic, leader qualifications, perceived usefulness of information,
available time, preferred referral from schools or doctors, available child care, and distance from
home (Babatsikos, 2010, p. 123). Ensuring that these logistical issues are addressed appropriately
will encourage parents to attend and implement child sexual abuse awareness and prevention
trainings. Partnering with community schools, where parent support and education about the
many issues is addressed, is likely a good venue to distribute information, due to the trust and
confidence that parents have in their children’s schools.
Other Stakeholders
In the fight to end child sexual abuse and educate parents to the warning signs there are a
number of community stakeholders that we reached out to. The community partner that we have
partnered with is Prevent Child Abuse Utah. Due to the limitations on the time of what we
hoped to accomplish and the nature of the assignment we knew that a community partner would
be critical. Prevent Child Abuse Utah or PCAU has been a service to the community since it
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 9
was founded in 1982 to educate children and adults around issues of abuse. PCAU facilitates a
number of different programs for schools, communities, and even within a home. They provide
training to parents, educators, and other professionals who work with children on the detection
and prevention of all forms of child abuse. Programs are also in place for children to be
educated on what constitutes abuse and safe ways of reporting if they are being perpetrated
against. In speaking with PCAU they voiced that despite having a presence for over thirty years
in Weber County they saw the need for greater access to the community. Many families were
unaware of their services and the educational materials they could provide.
In a study on the educators ability to take on the issues it was found that “while the
majority of teachers confront child abuse among their students, they are provided insufficient
education on how to address it” (Abrahams et al, 1992). Our communities have the protectors in
place, but we do a disservice in not providing them with all of the tools and knowledge to deal
with the situation. The fault does not come from a lack of resources, but rather a lack of
knowledge on where to access the resources. For this reason we identified schools as one of the
greatest stakeholders that we should work with. We have reached out to a few different schools
and have received some interest from Midvale Elementary and their district as a potential partner
in working with their students and parents.
Another stakeholder in this topic is society at large. In a published study on the monetary
cost on society of child abuse and neglect it was found that $33,101,302,133 annually is being
spent in costs attributed to directly correlated physical health, mental health, child welfare
programs, and law enforcement, with an additional estimated $103,754,017,492 indirect cost
(Wang & Holton, 2007). For many of the public the the eradication of child abuse and its
prevention is widely accepted as an appropriate course of action. For those who need an
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 10
economic incentive the numbers support the eradication of child abuse and neglect if only on the
basis of saving taxpayers hundreds of billions of dollars.
Our main community partner of Prevent Child Abuse Utah and the community schools
are our focus for the coming semester for the scope of our project. There are a number of other
agencies who we would like to work with, such as church groups and other counseling agencies.
The utilization of the thirty years of experience at PCAU and their programs that have been
developed will be key in helping us move forward and assisting in educating parents and other
key adults in the recognition of child abuse and knowledge of resources available to them.
CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE 11
References
Abrahams, N., Casey, K., & Daro, D. (1992). Teachers' knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs about
child abuse and its prevention. Child Abuse & Neglect, 16(2), 229-238.
Allen-Meares, P., Fraser, M.W. (2004). Intervention with children and adolescents: An
interdisciplinary perspective. Pearson Education, Inc.
American Psychological Association. (2007). Task force on the sexualization of girls: Report of
the APA task force on the sexualization of girls. Washington, DC: American
Psychological Association; 2007. Retrieved on December 10, 2014 from
http://www.apa.org/pi/wpo/sexualization.html.
Babatsikos, G. (2010). Parents’ knowledge, attitudes and practices about preventing child
sexual abuse: A literature review. Child Abuse Review, 19, 107-129.
doi:10:1002/car.1102
H.B. 286 Child Sex Abuse Prevention. (2014 General Session). Retrieved December 09, 2014,
from Utah State Legislature: http://le.utah.gov/~2014/bills/static/hb0286.html
Walsh, K. & Brandon, L. (2012). Their children’s first educators: Parents’ views about child
sexual abuse prevention education. Journal of Child & Family Studies, 21, 734-746.
doi:10.1007/s10826-011-9526-4
Wang, C., & Holton, J. (2007). Total estimated cost of child abuse and neglect in the united
states. Prevent child abuse utah, 1-5.
Wurtele, S. K., & Kenny, M. C. (2010). Partnering with parents to prevent childhood sexual
abuse. Child Abuse Review, 19(2), 130–152.
Wurtele, S. K. (2009). Preventing sexual abuse of children in the twenty-first century: Preparing
for challenges and opportunities. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 18(1), 1–18.
Friday, December 5, 2014
We Have a Winner!
Hurray! We have been approved to distribute our survey at Davis Behavioral Health in Layton, Utah.
The population that they serve is both the Children and Youth and Adult Outpatient. Most client's are Medicaid clients, court-ordered, or paying on a sliding scale fee. This reaches the lower economic status population that Diana found in her research are underrepresented and yet have a high number of incidents of child abuse reported.
The method for distributing these surveys would most likely be to have them complete a paper format. There is also a possibility of getting the survey to populate on the mini iPads that the parents use monthly to complete their child's Youth Outcome Questionnaire. These YOQ's are required the beginning of each month, so that would be the ideal time to pass out our survey and piggy-back on what they are already doing.
We also talked about offering a piece of candy for completing the survey, and possibly a prize drawing incentive as well. I would be able to get a nice pair of bluetooth headphones as the prize.
The population that they serve is both the Children and Youth and Adult Outpatient. Most client's are Medicaid clients, court-ordered, or paying on a sliding scale fee. This reaches the lower economic status population that Diana found in her research are underrepresented and yet have a high number of incidents of child abuse reported.
The method for distributing these surveys would most likely be to have them complete a paper format. There is also a possibility of getting the survey to populate on the mini iPads that the parents use monthly to complete their child's Youth Outcome Questionnaire. These YOQ's are required the beginning of each month, so that would be the ideal time to pass out our survey and piggy-back on what they are already doing.
We also talked about offering a piece of candy for completing the survey, and possibly a prize drawing incentive as well. I would be able to get a nice pair of bluetooth headphones as the prize.
Thursday, December 4, 2014
More on Survey Creation & Distribution
The survey has been created now on Qualtrics and is almost ready to be distributed. We went through it as a group and feel that there are a a few more questions that we could still add, such as getting more information about the demographics of the individuals taking the survey, possibly with race, socioeconomic status and religion. In some of the surveys we looked at for examples we saw that those were included and may give us a clearer picture if their are any distinctions or factors related to backgrounds that could shed more light on the issue. We also have begun organizing and writing our paper summarizing the project for our presentation next week.
Ian
The survey looks great, thanks for creating it Ian! Thanks for finding a good place to distribute it Katie! I agree that it will be helpful to learn more about the demographic information of the people answering the survey. I think that knowing more about the populations that we are helping, will help us to be more aware of important issues and needs of the populations that we want to serve. - Diana
I'm so glad to hear that we have been able to make further connections with stakeholders. After talking to my friend who works at DCFS, I have realized that he has considerable insight regarding sexual abuse awareness and perception specifically within the Utah county area. Hopefully this can also help build upon further qualitative understanding into this issue.
Besides that, I am wondering what all of your thoughts are in considering questions of demographics. Would it be best to have a section labeled race/ethnic background or would it be better to give it another title? What is the best way to state such a question? Do you guys have examples from assessment sheets you use at your internships? Anyways, go team! Glad things are continuing to move along smoothly. - Cameron
Ian
The survey looks great, thanks for creating it Ian! Thanks for finding a good place to distribute it Katie! I agree that it will be helpful to learn more about the demographic information of the people answering the survey. I think that knowing more about the populations that we are helping, will help us to be more aware of important issues and needs of the populations that we want to serve. - Diana
I'm so glad to hear that we have been able to make further connections with stakeholders. After talking to my friend who works at DCFS, I have realized that he has considerable insight regarding sexual abuse awareness and perception specifically within the Utah county area. Hopefully this can also help build upon further qualitative understanding into this issue.
Besides that, I am wondering what all of your thoughts are in considering questions of demographics. Would it be best to have a section labeled race/ethnic background or would it be better to give it another title? What is the best way to state such a question? Do you guys have examples from assessment sheets you use at your internships? Anyways, go team! Glad things are continuing to move along smoothly. - Cameron
Tuesday, November 25, 2014
Community Schools
Sonja Anderson form Midvale Elementary called me back today 11/25/14. She said that the best way to distribute our survey in the schools and educate parents regarding talking to children about sexual abuse is to work through the Canyons School District community school director, Michele Vogler. Sonja has spoken with Michele, and said that it should be a good fit. I think that we should finalize a few details before we talk to Michele. The school will be closed for the rest of the week because of the Thanksgiving holiday, Michele should be available to discuss the project next week.- Diana
Canyons School District Community Schools Coordinator:
Michele Vogler
801-826-5023
michele.vogler@canyonsdistrict.org
Canyons School District Community Schools Coordinator:
Michele Vogler
801-826-5023
michele.vogler@canyonsdistrict.org
Friday, November 21, 2014
Sample Survey Questions
Here are some survey questions that I came up with, let me know what you think. If we have enough good questions, I think that it would be okay to make the survey longer in order to make it more detailed and inclusive. What do you all think? - Diana
1) What are the age ranges of your children? Please mark all that apply.
a) 0-5
b) 6-10
c) 11-14
d) 15-18
2) Do you see child sexual abuse as rare or unusual?
a) Yes
b) No
3) Is it more common for child sexual abusers to be:
a) A stranger
b) Someone known to the child (family member, family friend, neighbor)ĥ
4) Have you discussed sexual abuse with your child?
a) Yes
b) No
5) Do you feel comfortable discussing sexual abuse with your child?
a) Yes
b) No
6) Do you feel that you have the knowledge and vocabulary to discuss sexual abuse with your child?
a) Yes
b) No
7) Who do you believe should be the primary educator of your child regarding child sexual abuse?
a) school
b) child's friends
c) parents
d) siblings
e) T.V., newspaper, radio
8) What level of risk do you feel your child is at for being the victims of sexual abuse?
a) High
b) Low
9) Where did you receive the information that you will use to educate your child about sexual abuse?
a) T.V., newspaper, radio
b) media
c) doctor
c) child abuse education programs
d) nowhere specific, life lessons learned by growing older
e) other, please specify ____________________________________________
10) Did your parents talk to you about sexual abuse and prevention when you were a child?
a) Yes
b) No
11) Do you feel comfortable discussing child sexual abuse and prevention with your child's pediatrician?
a) Yes
b) No
12) In your household, who would be most likely to talk with your child about sexual abuse?
a) Mother
b) Father
c) Both mother and father together
d) No one
13) Would you find it important and worth your time to take a parent education course regarding how to talk to children about sexual abuse?
a) Yes
b) No
14) How knowledgeable do you feel your child currently is regarding sexual abuse issues and protection strategies?
a) Very high
b) High
c) Moderate
d) Low
e) Very low
15) At what age should children first be introduced to sexual abuse issues, and taught personal safety skills?
a) 1-2 years old
a) Preschool age
b) Elementary school age
c) Middle school age
d) High school age
e) Never, if children are not introduced to problems regarding sexual abuse they are less likely to occur
16) Additional comments regarding this survey.
__________________________________________________________
Here are some survey questions that I came up with, let me know what you think. If we have enough good questions, I think that it would be okay to make the survey longer in order to make it more detailed and inclusive. What do you all think? - Diana
1) What are the age ranges of your children? Please mark all that apply.
a) 0-5
b) 6-10
c) 11-14
d) 15-18
2) Do you see child sexual abuse as rare or unusual?
a) Yes
b) No
3) Is it more common for child sexual abusers to be:
a) A stranger
b) Someone known to the child (family member, family friend, neighbor)ĥ
4) Have you discussed sexual abuse with your child?
a) Yes
b) No
5) Do you feel comfortable discussing sexual abuse with your child?
a) Yes
b) No
6) Do you feel that you have the knowledge and vocabulary to discuss sexual abuse with your child?
a) Yes
b) No
7) Who do you believe should be the primary educator of your child regarding child sexual abuse?
a) school
b) child's friends
c) parents
d) siblings
e) T.V., newspaper, radio
8) What level of risk do you feel your child is at for being the victims of sexual abuse?
a) High
b) Low
9) Where did you receive the information that you will use to educate your child about sexual abuse?
a) T.V., newspaper, radio
b) media
c) doctor
c) child abuse education programs
d) nowhere specific, life lessons learned by growing older
e) other, please specify ____________________________________________
10) Did your parents talk to you about sexual abuse and prevention when you were a child?
a) Yes
b) No
11) Do you feel comfortable discussing child sexual abuse and prevention with your child's pediatrician?
a) Yes
b) No
12) In your household, who would be most likely to talk with your child about sexual abuse?
a) Mother
b) Father
c) Both mother and father together
d) No one
13) Would you find it important and worth your time to take a parent education course regarding how to talk to children about sexual abuse?
a) Yes
b) No
14) How knowledgeable do you feel your child currently is regarding sexual abuse issues and protection strategies?
a) Very high
b) High
c) Moderate
d) Low
e) Very low
15) At what age should children first be introduced to sexual abuse issues, and taught personal safety skills?
a) 1-2 years old
a) Preschool age
b) Elementary school age
c) Middle school age
d) High school age
e) Never, if children are not introduced to problems regarding sexual abuse they are less likely to occur
16) Additional comments regarding this survey.
__________________________________________________________
Survey questions/Facebook distribution
Hello all!
After talking today, I think we overall have plenty of great questions to use in the survey. After speaking to my friend who works for DCFS, he was able to help me write a few more questions that may also be of help:
Who would you report suspected child abuse to? (select all that apply)
a. Child and Family Services
b. Police
c. Church Leadership
d. Family
e. Nobody
-correct answers: a and b
Which of these choices is considered sexual abuse? (select all that apply)
a. A 17 year old having consensual sex with a 16 year old.
b. A 5 year old exploring genetalia with another 5 year old.
c. A minor finds their parent's pornography collection.
d. A parent showering his or her 12 year old daughter with no sexual intent.
e. An adult touches the buttocks of a minor for sexual gratification.
f. None of the above.
-correct answers: c and e
Any report made of child sexual abuse will be kept anonymous unless the informant states otherwise
a. True
b. False
-correct answer: a
Also, once we have this survey completed this weekend, I will post it on the group Facebook page and we can distribute it to friends and ask them to forward it on. Also, I will do my best to send it out to people at random within the Salt Lake area. Hopefully between both approaches we will be able to acquire plenty of response.
Cameron
After talking today, I think we overall have plenty of great questions to use in the survey. After speaking to my friend who works for DCFS, he was able to help me write a few more questions that may also be of help:
Who would you report suspected child abuse to? (select all that apply)
a. Child and Family Services
b. Police
c. Church Leadership
d. Family
e. Nobody
-correct answers: a and b
Which of these choices is considered sexual abuse? (select all that apply)
a. A 17 year old having consensual sex with a 16 year old.
b. A 5 year old exploring genetalia with another 5 year old.
c. A minor finds their parent's pornography collection.
d. A parent showering his or her 12 year old daughter with no sexual intent.
e. An adult touches the buttocks of a minor for sexual gratification.
f. None of the above.
-correct answers: c and e
Any report made of child sexual abuse will be kept anonymous unless the informant states otherwise
a. True
b. False
-correct answer: a
Also, once we have this survey completed this weekend, I will post it on the group Facebook page and we can distribute it to friends and ask them to forward it on. Also, I will do my best to send it out to people at random within the Salt Lake area. Hopefully between both approaches we will be able to acquire plenty of response.
Cameron
Facebook page
Hey all,
I created a Facebook page for our survey group. Sign in with our usual email address and password. I posted a description of our project on the timeline, feel free to make changes as you feel is appropriate. I had to put my personal name in to make the account, but I made it so that all posts, likes, etc will be shown as "Child Abuse Awareness for Parents" rather than my name.
I didn't put a picture, I "liked" the University of Utah and Prevent Child Abuse Utah. It might make us feel a little more legitimate to survey takers if we friended the page or something so they can see that we actually exist.
Any ideas and feedback is welcome! :)
Laurel
I created a Facebook page for our survey group. Sign in with our usual email address and password. I posted a description of our project on the timeline, feel free to make changes as you feel is appropriate. I had to put my personal name in to make the account, but I made it so that all posts, likes, etc will be shown as "Child Abuse Awareness for Parents" rather than my name.
I didn't put a picture, I "liked" the University of Utah and Prevent Child Abuse Utah. It might make us feel a little more legitimate to survey takers if we friended the page or something so they can see that we actually exist.
Any ideas and feedback is welcome! :)
Laurel
Thursday, November 20, 2014
Survey 2.0 + Meeting
We decided that using survey monkey might discourage people from participating as it is a less formal site. I created an account with qualtrics. Their program is much more professional and gives us more information and ways of looking at the reaponses given. Hopefully this change will help parents feel more comfortable with the credibility of our survey. Prevent Child Abuse Utah also gave us permission to add their logo to the survey after they had a chance to approve it. We are still trying to figure out the best way to disseminate it and are looking into using Facebook.
Ian
This week I contacted Jordan School District to ask if they would support us in distributing the child sexual abuse awareness survey for parents in schools, and down the road allow us to hold parent education classes regarding teaching children about sexual abuse. They said no, that their focus is on child education, not parent education.
I then contacted Midvale Elementary School in the Canyons School District. Their principal was not in, and I spoke with Sonja Anderson (801-826-8350), the school social worker, who seemed interested in and supportive of the project. I told her that we are partnering with Prevent Child Abuse Utah. She took notes about our project and said that she would discuss it with the principal and call me back next week. I believe that this will fit well with the community school model at Midvale Elementary School. I will post again when I speak with Sonja again.
Our group met twice this week and made good progress, setting up a new survey site, and a group Facebook page. I set up two google docs for our group presentation, one for the power point, and one for the paper, so that we can work on the presentation together. Good job group! - Diana
Ian
This week I contacted Jordan School District to ask if they would support us in distributing the child sexual abuse awareness survey for parents in schools, and down the road allow us to hold parent education classes regarding teaching children about sexual abuse. They said no, that their focus is on child education, not parent education.
I then contacted Midvale Elementary School in the Canyons School District. Their principal was not in, and I spoke with Sonja Anderson (801-826-8350), the school social worker, who seemed interested in and supportive of the project. I told her that we are partnering with Prevent Child Abuse Utah. She took notes about our project and said that she would discuss it with the principal and call me back next week. I believe that this will fit well with the community school model at Midvale Elementary School. I will post again when I speak with Sonja again.
Our group met twice this week and made good progress, setting up a new survey site, and a group Facebook page. I set up two google docs for our group presentation, one for the power point, and one for the paper, so that we can work on the presentation together. Good job group! - Diana
Friday, November 7, 2014
Great Website and Sample Survey
So, I was pulling up a website on protecting children, and as I did so, a survey popped up... just my luck. I copied their survey to get an idea of how to format our own survey. Check it out.
(Oh, and the website link too! :) ) http://www.parentsprotect.co.uk/warning_signs.htm#
(Oh, and the website link too! :) ) http://www.parentsprotect.co.uk/warning_signs.htm#
Usage and Evaluation Survey
Thank you for visiting the Parents Protect! website. This short survey will only take a 3 minutes. We really value your feedback which will help us to help others.
Thank you for visiting the Parents Protect! website. This short survey will only take a 3 minutes. We really value your feedback which will help us to help others.
Survey
Survey Questions
Please answer each question on a scale of 1-10.
1 = very low or very little
10 = very high or very much
How safe do you feel that your neighborhood is for your children?
How well do you know your neighbors?
How much do you trust your neighbors?
How often have you spoken with your children about sexual abuse prevention?
How comfortable do you feel about speaking to your children about sexual abuse?
How much does your child know about the dangers of sexual abuse?
What are the ages of your children? (not on a 1-10 scale)
What do you think about making a survey for children as well as adults? This way we could refer to information in the child survey when finding relevant information to teach parents and other adults down the road in our project. - Diana
I think this is a great survey format. It is quite simple and quick to use, which will help ensure that people are more willing to complete it. My main feedback would be that we would need to find the right survey website that would allow us to use a scale of 1-10. I'm not sure that Survey Monkey will do that but we can look further into it. Also, I do have good news. It appears that facebook could be a useful method of randomly distributing the survey. We can easily search for all people within the Salt Lake area and message them at random with the survey. The only thing I think would be necessary for that to work would be to actually set up a facebook page specifically for this project so people believe we are legitimate. What are everyone's thoughts? Thanks and take care! - Cameron
I found an article on what impacts the likelihood of people answering surveys about child abuse. Granted, the survey was to adults about their own childhood experiences and it was quite detailed, but it might be helpful.
I'll keep looking to see if there are more resources that are better fitted to our project. - Laurel
Please answer each question on a scale of 1-10.
1 = very low or very little
10 = very high or very much
How safe do you feel that your neighborhood is for your children?
How well do you know your neighbors?
How much do you trust your neighbors?
How often have you spoken with your children about sexual abuse prevention?
How comfortable do you feel about speaking to your children about sexual abuse?
How much does your child know about the dangers of sexual abuse?
What are the ages of your children? (not on a 1-10 scale)
What do you think about making a survey for children as well as adults? This way we could refer to information in the child survey when finding relevant information to teach parents and other adults down the road in our project. - Diana
I think this is a great survey format. It is quite simple and quick to use, which will help ensure that people are more willing to complete it. My main feedback would be that we would need to find the right survey website that would allow us to use a scale of 1-10. I'm not sure that Survey Monkey will do that but we can look further into it. Also, I do have good news. It appears that facebook could be a useful method of randomly distributing the survey. We can easily search for all people within the Salt Lake area and message them at random with the survey. The only thing I think would be necessary for that to work would be to actually set up a facebook page specifically for this project so people believe we are legitimate. What are everyone's thoughts? Thanks and take care! - Cameron
I found an article on what impacts the likelihood of people answering surveys about child abuse. Granted, the survey was to adults about their own childhood experiences and it was quite detailed, but it might be helpful.
Bias assessment for child abuse survey:: Factors affecting probability of response to a survey about childhood abuse
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0145213400002386I'll keep looking to see if there are more resources that are better fitted to our project. - Laurel
Survey questions
we are still working on finalizing the survey and figuring out where we will distribute it. I had a personal example this week from my mother in law not knowing where to get information on how to talk to her daughter about if she had experienced any sexual abuse at the hands of their neighbor. She ended up calling the police to ask for what she should do. Fortunately my sister in law was ok, but it just highlighted for me the need for the resources we are trying to put together.
Ian
Ian
Friday, October 24, 2014
Child Abuse Wheel and Equality Wheel
http://www.ncdsv.org/publications_wheel.html
(to access this link, copy and paste it into your browser)
I love this resource! It consists of two wheels, a child abuse wheel and equality wheel, based off of the original domestic violence wheel. The child abuse wheel specifically explains signs of child abuse, including physical, emotional, verbal, and sexual abuse components. This helps children and parents to identify signs of child abuse. I think that the equality wheel is also a crucial resource, because it helps parents and children identify a healthy relationship, and differentiate it from an abusive one. This is diverse resource that can be processed in an individual or group therapy setting, or can be presented in a larger group, taking a psycho-educational approach. I love that these wheels are informative and easy to understand. Teaching the concepts from these wheels will inform parents and children, and help them to recognize and be aware of the difference between healthy/safe and unhealthy/unsafe relationships. These wheels can be used as effective tools to help prevent, as well as detect child abuse. -Diana
(to access this link, copy and paste it into your browser)
I love this resource! It consists of two wheels, a child abuse wheel and equality wheel, based off of the original domestic violence wheel. The child abuse wheel specifically explains signs of child abuse, including physical, emotional, verbal, and sexual abuse components. This helps children and parents to identify signs of child abuse. I think that the equality wheel is also a crucial resource, because it helps parents and children identify a healthy relationship, and differentiate it from an abusive one. This is diverse resource that can be processed in an individual or group therapy setting, or can be presented in a larger group, taking a psycho-educational approach. I love that these wheels are informative and easy to understand. Teaching the concepts from these wheels will inform parents and children, and help them to recognize and be aware of the difference between healthy/safe and unhealthy/unsafe relationships. These wheels can be used as effective tools to help prevent, as well as detect child abuse. -Diana
Thursday, October 23, 2014
Resources
I have been looking up different resources that would be helpful for our project. I have found the following resourcesinformative and interesting:
Our in class discussion we talked about some of the different community resources that we could tap into. We talked about the school districts and that they may have some programs in place that we could incorporate as well as Prevent Child Abuse Utah. We discovered that some of these groups already have resources and perhaps what we need to do is help increase visibility and accessibility to these resources rather than trying to reinvent the wheel. -Ian
The assigned tasks this past meeting included Katie looking further into opportunities to attend a Child Abuse awareness event, and each of us continuing to brainstorm survey questions to be used in measuring public awareness as well as finding further resources for information on child abuse.
-Cameron
- www.rainn.org - my favorite, gives good information, easy to understand
- nsopw.gov
- focus on the family.com - this website gives useful statistics about sexual abuse
- www.stop it now.org
- Huffington Post - safe touch and not safe touch - better to teach children, vs. good and bad touch - not good to teach children, easy for children to misunderstand this language.
- Oprah clip - 4 things parents should know about sexual abuse
- 10 ways to talk to your children about sexual abuse
- www.childhelp.org - 3 main things to tell kids about sexual abuse:
- Explain types of touch
- Teach child to say "no"
- Teach children to speak up
Within the next few weeks I will begin to facilitate an "Adults Molested As Children" group at my practicum. I have begun to study some information for this group that is informative. - Diana
Our in class discussion we talked about some of the different community resources that we could tap into. We talked about the school districts and that they may have some programs in place that we could incorporate as well as Prevent Child Abuse Utah. We discovered that some of these groups already have resources and perhaps what we need to do is help increase visibility and accessibility to these resources rather than trying to reinvent the wheel. -Ian
The assigned tasks this past meeting included Katie looking further into opportunities to attend a Child Abuse awareness event, and each of us continuing to brainstorm survey questions to be used in measuring public awareness as well as finding further resources for information on child abuse.
-Cameron
Survey Questions
Hey all! Here are some ideas for questions we could put on the surveys for the project:
- What knowledge do you have now about child abuse?
- As a parent, what would be some the pros and cons of discussing child abuse with your child?
- If you found out your child was abused, what steps would you take?
- Who would you feel most comfortable talking about the topic of child abuse with? (clergy member, therapist, school counselor)
- How many signs of child abuse do you know?
Some of these could probably be more delicately stated, but there's the general idea.
Laurel
Here are a few more questions I have thought of:
- If you were to witness child abuse, what would be your possible hesitations in reporting it?
- T/F Child abuse reporting is a legal requirement of any witness.
- What agency would be best to call upon witnessing child abuse?
- Would you be willing to attend any training on child abuse awareness if given the chance?
- How frequently do you believe child abuse happens in your neighborhood?
- Have you ever witnessed or experienced child abuse before? If so, circle the following types: Sexual, Emotional, Physical.
Cameron
I am thinking it might be best to keep most of the answers as quantitative as possible. I worry that if we have too many questions that are open ended it will make our data harder to use. Some qualitative questions could be really helpful though.
I am liking the questions that we have come up with, I think as long as we are able to come up with a/b/c/d options and possibly an "other" where they can fill in additional information if they wish. I have started the survey monkey survey, so now we just need to finish it up and figure out how we are going to disseminate it to the widest possible populations. We also talked about naming it something a little more ambiguous to cast a wider net, which is something that I would support, as we included a few more general parenting type questions.
Ian
I agree with Ian. Qualitative responses would probably help most in our short time we have to compile and analyze the data. I like the ideas and questions posted. Ian, do you have more of the questions that we created together when we met before break?
Also, I will be attending the Joining Forces Conference next Monday, and I can get an idea about what is available information out there already.
- What knowledge do you have now about child abuse?
- As a parent, what would be some the pros and cons of discussing child abuse with your child?
- If you found out your child was abused, what steps would you take?
- Who would you feel most comfortable talking about the topic of child abuse with? (clergy member, therapist, school counselor)
- How many signs of child abuse do you know?
Some of these could probably be more delicately stated, but there's the general idea.
Laurel
Here are a few more questions I have thought of:
- If you were to witness child abuse, what would be your possible hesitations in reporting it?
- T/F Child abuse reporting is a legal requirement of any witness.
- What agency would be best to call upon witnessing child abuse?
- Would you be willing to attend any training on child abuse awareness if given the chance?
- How frequently do you believe child abuse happens in your neighborhood?
- Have you ever witnessed or experienced child abuse before? If so, circle the following types: Sexual, Emotional, Physical.
Cameron
I am thinking it might be best to keep most of the answers as quantitative as possible. I worry that if we have too many questions that are open ended it will make our data harder to use. Some qualitative questions could be really helpful though.
I am liking the questions that we have come up with, I think as long as we are able to come up with a/b/c/d options and possibly an "other" where they can fill in additional information if they wish. I have started the survey monkey survey, so now we just need to finish it up and figure out how we are going to disseminate it to the widest possible populations. We also talked about naming it something a little more ambiguous to cast a wider net, which is something that I would support, as we included a few more general parenting type questions.
Ian
I agree with Ian. Qualitative responses would probably help most in our short time we have to compile and analyze the data. I like the ideas and questions posted. Ian, do you have more of the questions that we created together when we met before break?
Also, I will be attending the Joining Forces Conference next Monday, and I can get an idea about what is available information out there already.
Friday, October 3, 2014
Thursday, October 2, 2014
Resources for project
I was thinking of ways that we could help get the word out, including what I could do specifically. I am course happy to talk with my practicum and work agencies to see if they would be on board with distributing some surveys. Both of these agencies are with youth and we work heavily with children and families who are dealing with child abuse. Also, we could think about posting surveys on Facebook or other social media as well to see what kind of responses we get that way. Regarding what Cameron talked about as far as media networks and what we have been discussing, I also have one or two media contacts that I may be able to utilize. Talk to you all soon!
Laurel
Thinking of social media, do you think we could get a representative sample if we invited tons of people in the salt lake area at random to join a Child Abuse Utah group? If we enter a search of adults in the Salt Lake area and pick the nth person (maybe 200 total) to invite to the group, maybe this can help eliminate competing and extraneous variables in the survey.
-Cameron
Laurel
Thinking of social media, do you think we could get a representative sample if we invited tons of people in the salt lake area at random to join a Child Abuse Utah group? If we enter a search of adults in the Salt Lake area and pick the nth person (maybe 200 total) to invite to the group, maybe this can help eliminate competing and extraneous variables in the survey.
-Cameron
Friday, September 19, 2014
Why this Project?
Our group project is to raise awareness of the reality of child abuse right here in Utah. In fact, every 10 seconds, there is a new report of child abuse that has taken place somewhere in Utah. According to statistics from Prevent Child Abuse Utah, 1 in 4 girls and 1 in 6 boys experience some form of abide by the time that they are eighteen. Our hope is to raise awareness and then improve communication between parents, or caregivers and children. The number one prevention strategy is for children to feel comfortable talking with their parents or caregiver. We want to help bridge that gap, and create comfortable dialogue on the part of both parent and child.
Problem Statement: (as of October 2, 2014)
Problem Statement: (as of October 2, 2014)
Child sexual abuse takes place in Utah, yet parents continue
to be unaware and unprepared to recognize the signs and symptoms of this abuse
taking place.
Saturday, September 13, 2014
Members of our group, Abuse Awareness for Parents with Children, are Katie, Laurel, Diana, Ian, and Cameron. We met as a group yesterday to become better acquainted and discuss our ideas for direction and goals of our group. Everyone in our group was present for the group meeting. We will be working with Prevent Child Abuse Utah (PCAU), whose core values are to protect and value children, strengthen families, and engage communities. To get started, Katie will meet with Trina at PCAU to better define our group's role in creating a task force for PCAU. Our group will then meet again to discuss the meeting with Trina, and assign tasks to each group member. I am excited about this project because I love working with children and families, and protecting and valuing children, strengthening families, and engaging communities are all values that really resonate with me. - Diana
A few of the clients that I am working with at my practicum are adults who were abused as children or are children that have recently been abused. I am hoping that I can learn a little bit more about childhood abuse for this project that I can use to assist my clients, as well as use the work with my clients to inform what is done with our project. - Ian
After discussing our plans the other day, I have thought of a few ideas of ways which we can get the word out on abuse. For one, we can reach out to local news media (sltrib, KSL, and Fox) as a possible means of bringing attention to the cause. By doing so, if we hypothetically had a large awareness event such as a 5k going on, we could easily advertise it through those news sources if they were interested. Another idea I had would be to help evoke intrinsic motivation within the community by spreading statistics specifically stating the prevalence of chid abuse within Utah, Salt Lake, Davis, and Weber counties. This could hopefully help people realize this is likely going on in their own neighborhoods. These are just some ideas I had to help brainstorm our intervention, and hopefully these can be of some help in addition to what we learn from PCAU. Looking forward to seeing you all on Thursday! - Cameron
A few of the clients that I am working with at my practicum are adults who were abused as children or are children that have recently been abused. I am hoping that I can learn a little bit more about childhood abuse for this project that I can use to assist my clients, as well as use the work with my clients to inform what is done with our project. - Ian
After discussing our plans the other day, I have thought of a few ideas of ways which we can get the word out on abuse. For one, we can reach out to local news media (sltrib, KSL, and Fox) as a possible means of bringing attention to the cause. By doing so, if we hypothetically had a large awareness event such as a 5k going on, we could easily advertise it through those news sources if they were interested. Another idea I had would be to help evoke intrinsic motivation within the community by spreading statistics specifically stating the prevalence of chid abuse within Utah, Salt Lake, Davis, and Weber counties. This could hopefully help people realize this is likely going on in their own neighborhoods. These are just some ideas I had to help brainstorm our intervention, and hopefully these can be of some help in addition to what we learn from PCAU. Looking forward to seeing you all on Thursday! - Cameron
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)